TL;DR LA POSTFIRE Phase 1 Debris Removal Q&A #4
TL;DR
LA Post Fire: Phase 1 Debris Removal
Host: iO Tillet- Wright, wildfire survivor and activist
https://www.iolovesyou.com/, postfirela.org
Guest: Harry Allen, a Federal On-Scene Coordinator for the EPA. Allen has 27 years of experience, with 22 years at the EPA, specializing in spill and chemical release remediation. https://www.linkedin.com/in/harryalleniv/
Video of this conversation can be found here:
https://youtu.be/q2gVPV4StYs?si=B2L6DtQzjZRV19K5
● Focus of EPA's Phase One Debris Removal:
○ Phase one entails removing hazardous and partially burned household chemicals (e.g., propane cans, paint, pesticides, oil) and electronic waste (e.g., burnt TVs, CPUs, solar panels).
○ It does not involve the removal of ash, soil, or widespread toxins, which are part of phase two.
○ Loose asbestos is marked or removed, but full asbestos and toxin removal occur in later stages.
● Clarification of EPA Responsibilities:
○ EPA focuses on removing materials that could be hazardous if left behind or improperly disposed of.
○ Ash and other toxic debris remain until phase two, handled by state and county agencies.
○ California has specific regulations for proper disposal of burned materials to prevent health risks and environmental damage.
○ The public often confuses EPA’s role with broader recovery tasks, leading to frustration when certain questions cannot be answered.
○ Harry emphasizes the need to direct questions about air, water, beaches, soil, and re-entry to local agencies, such as Public Works or the county.
○ Cleaning of Intact Buildings: Responsibility for cleaning is likely with County Health, not the EPA
Items Removed During Cleanup:
● Hazardous Household Chemicals: Paint cans, pesticides, etc.
● Cylinders: Propane, oxygen, acetylene, butane (if not combusted).
● Asbestos: Small bits of asbestos material are removed if obvious.
● Ammunition: Burned ammunition is removed and handed to the sheriff. ● Lithium-ion Batteries: Found in phones, laptops, vape pens, tools, toys, e-bikes, EVs, etc. Removed as they pose fire risks after exposure to fire or flood.
Risks and Hazards:
● Battery Combustion: Damaged lithium-ion batteries can ignite, causing jet-fire-like explosions.
● Unexploded Items: Drones, toys, and vape pens may still pose combustion risks post-fire.
● Environmental Concerns: Ash can get into air and water during cleanup, although precise risks are still under investigation.
Transportation and Disposal Process:
● Materials are double-bagged at the burn site before transport.
● Trucks with plastic liners are used to prevent contamination during transit. ● At staging areas:
○ Materials are sorted under a tent.
○ Items are placed in specialized containers (e.g., red bins for asbestos). ○ Containers are sealed and sent to appropriate disposal facilities.
Cleanup Protocols:
● Crews include experts for hazardous materials and asbestos, equipped with: ○ Air, dust, radiation, and gas monitoring tools.
○ Protective gear (respirators, full suits, hard hats, etc.).
● Teams inspect sites, identify hazards, and collect dangerous items.
● Waste is segregated by type (e.g., batteries, asbestos, paint) for proper disposal. Progress Tracking:
● EPA Progress Map:
○ Tracks cleanup phases (Phase 1: hazard removal, Phase 2: broader debris cleanup).
○ Properties are color-coded:
■ Yellow: Phase 1 needed.
■ Blue: Phase 1 completed.
○ Updates occur in real-time as properties are cleared.
● Property Access and Categories:
○ No Access: If property owners prohibit access (e.g., fences, chains), work cannot proceed.
○ Unsafe Properties: Some properties are deemed unsafe (e.g., leaning walls, chimneys, basements) and deferred directly to the construction phase.
● Phased Cleanup Approach:
○ Traditionally, cleanup phases were sequential, but now both phase one and phase two occur simultaneously to allow people to return to properties sooner. ○ Coordination between EPA and the Army Corps ensures work can progress on neighboring properties without waiting for adjacent areas.
● Timeline and Workforce:
○ Over 13,500 properties need cleanup, including 6,600 from the Eden Fire. ○ A large team is involved, including 700+ technicians, 80–100 Hazmat specialists, and support personnel from across the U.S.
○ Current goal: Increase from 60 to 80 teams to expedite the process.
● Cleanup and Safety Guidelines:
○ Ash and debris contain hazards such as heavy metals, lead, and asbestos. ○ Protective measures include wearing gloves, booties, steel-shank boots, P100 respirators, hazmat suits, and goggles.
○ Ash is highly alkaline (pH of 12) and can burn skin and eyes. Avoid bringing ash into cars or homes.
○ Walking in burn zones is dangerous due to hidden hazards (e.g., nails, falling debris).
● Air Quality and Hazards:
○ Fine particles like asbestos can cause long-term lung damage if inhaled. ○ Wearing proper masks (e.g., P100 respirators) is critical to prevent inhaling harmful particles.
● Coordination and Monitoring:
○ Teams use a mapping system to track daily progress and areas of operation, visible to the public for transparency.
○ Efforts are made to avoid neighborhood congestion by staggering cleanup operations.
● Disposal of Materials:
○ Trucks transporting debris are secure to prevent risks of materials flying out. ○ Disposal facilities and staging areas are monitored to ensure proper handling of hazardous waste.
● Expert Recommendations:
○ Experts emphasize the importance of thorough personal protection when visiting burn sites.
○ Additional precautions like avoiding ash contact and proper footwear are critical for safety.
General Safety and Risk Management:
● Minimal risk of materials flying out of trucks due to secure bagging and containment. ● Low risk of materials contaminating water supply or soil, as they are safely stored and transported.
Disposal and Staging Concerns:
● Misunderstandings exist about where removed materials are staged and disposed of. ● Materials like asbestos are sent to asbestos-only landfills with stringent handling protocols.
● E-waste and hazardous chemicals are transported to specialized recycling or disposal facilities.
● California has robust programs for the safe disposal of asbestos, e-waste, and hazardous materials.
Transportation and Legal Compliance:
● Transport involves detailed agreements with receiving facilities, manifests, and proper labeling.
● Materials are inspected, bagged, and sorted following strict legal and safety guidelines.
Specific Disposal Examples:
● Asbestos: Sent to dedicated landfills in sealed bags.
● E-waste: Sent to permitted recycling facilities.
● Metal debris: Scrapped if non-hazardous.
● Hazardous chemicals: Sent to specialized facilities in California, Nevada, or other states. ● Unique or unknown substances: Tested in the field or with advanced lab equipment before disposal.
Access and Cleanup Process:
● If access to damaged properties (e.g., garages) is an issue, residents can contact the EPA hotline for assistance.
● Hotline: 833-798-7372 (or R9 US EPA for old-fashioned contact).
Tree Markings and Safety:
● Trees are inspected by arborists to assess hazards:
○ White "X": High risk of falling.
○ Equal sign: Medium hazard.
○ Arrow: Overhead hazards like branches at risk of falling.
● Arborists work to ensure worker safety in cleanup zones.
Site Selection Challenges:
● Initial sites like Will Rogers were vetoed due to competition with other organizations and local opposition.
● Current sites, like Topanga Canyon, are acknowledged to have challenges (size, traffic, flood zones, cultural significance).
● Efforts are being made to address community concerns and collaborate with stakeholders, including tribal representatives and state park officials.
Community Concerns:
● Residents express concerns about pollution risks and the safety of chosen staging sites. ● Ongoing negotiations may lead to reconsideration of staging areas like Will Rogers. ● Staging areas for hazardous waste are monitored with seven air quality stations for dust, gases, and toxins.
● No health risks from staging areas; concerns primarily involve traffic.
● Residents can report issues via hotline (833-798-7372).]
● Safety and Site Management:
○ Collaboration with trained experts, including Native Indian representatives and landslide experts, ensures safety at the sites.
○ Army Corps of Engineers manages sites with environmental controls. ○ Operations prioritize safety, minimizing risks like landslides or debris falls.
● Project Timelines:
○ The team has 30 days (starting January 25th) to complete Phase 1 of debris removal, currently around 10% complete.
● Focus on Community Impact:
○ The EPA team includes locals affected by disasters, emphasizing commitment to restoring their communities.
○ The project aims to reduce the burden on affected sites and prepare for long-term recovery.
Health and Safety Advice
● Returning Home:
○ Residents should prioritize safety, as disaster zones can pose risks like accidents.
○ Long-term recovery will address ash and debris removal through Phase 2 operations.
● Air Quality Concerns:
○ Residents can monitor air quality via the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD).
Resources & Support
● Information Access:
○ Residents can join the survivors' network at postfirela.org for updates and Q&A sessions.
○ EPA hotline: 833-798-7372 for complaints or concerns.